Most Chief AI Officers Lack Real Authority Over Investment Decisions, IBM Study Finds
An IBM Institute for Business Value survey of 1,600 global chief AI officers reveals a critical gap: while these leaders understand AI's enterprise value, only 18% control actual investment decisions, and governance constraints slow most organizations' ability to act on AI insights.

Chief AI officers occupy a unique vantage point to assess how artificial intelligence creates value across their organizations, yet most lack the authority to act on that knowledge, according to research released this week by the IBM Institute for Business Value. Among 1,600 chief AI officers surveyed globally, just 18% report having full control over decisions to allocate AI investment funds.
The authority gap extends beyond budgeting. Fewer than 30% of surveyed tech leaders said their organizations can reallocate resources and adjust course quickly when AI performance data suggests new priorities. Three-quarters of respondents identified governance, risk and compliance requirements as obstacles that impede their ability to move forward, the research showed.
To expand their influence, chief AI officers should ground their recommendations in measurable evidence about where processes require transformation, which projects merit expansion or termination, and how capital should flow, according to Radha Plumb, VP of data and AI-first Transformation at IBM. She told CIO Dive via email that "CAIO impact must be earned by using evidence to make value, tackle barriers, and make trade-offs visible to key stakeholders to try to drive cross-functional business transformation."
The Expanding Role
As enterprises accelerate their AI deployments, the chief AI officer position is becoming more prevalent across corporate hierarchies. According to Crist Kolder Associates, roughly 11% of Fortune 500 and S&P 500 companies now employ someone in a chief AI officer role or an equivalent position. Organizations that have designated someone to oversee AI initiatives have demonstrated superior returns on their AI investments compared to those without dedicated oversight, a separate October study by Wharton Human-AI Research and GBK Collective determined.
Yet the question of who owns AI strategy and holds decision-making power remains unsettled in many enterprises. Although most chief information officers expect to be held accountable when AI systems fail, relatively few possess genuine authority over how AI budgets are spent.
Chief information officers can serve as partners to chief AI officers by establishing frameworks and delivering measurable outcomes, Plumb suggested. She emphasized that information technology, data management and AI functions should operate from a unified roadmap and shared business metrics. "That means building capabilities once and reusing them across the business, retiring systems that AI makes redundant and sharing one view of where AI investment is paying off," she said.
The IBM research found that four in 10 chief AI officers do engage in conversations when performance data reveals promising opportunities, but implementation frequently stalls.
Structural Challenges
The chief AI officer role represents relatively new organizational territory for many companies, positioned at the intersection of multiple business functions and departments, Plumb noted. This placement, however, gives these leaders one of the broadest perspectives on how AI generates value throughout the enterprise.
Early chief AI officers were frequently recruited primarily to establish policies and mitigate risk. While that responsibility persists, the most effective chief AI officers have shifted focus toward implementation and delivery, Plumb explained. "They are accountable for getting AI into production and for what it returns to the business."
In numerous organizations, information technology, data and AI functions have operated as separate units with distinct budget allocations, Plumb noted. This fragmentation made sense when AI remained confined to pilot projects, but the technology now permeates essential business processes across enterprises.
Plumb stressed that achieving AI success requires coordinated decisions spanning strategy, investment allocation, operational frameworks and oversight mechanisms. "No single function or executive can make these changes independently," she said.


